Showing posts with label Recruiting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Recruiting. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 08, 2008

Grades

Hey Zookies,

Take a look at the grades that the Gator football team has achieved ever since we got rid of moRon Zook:

Spring 2005 2.45

Fall 2005 2.65

Spring 2006 2.68

Fall 2006 2.72

Spring 2007 2.77

Fall 2007 2.81

Watch Zook turn your program into a profe$$ional football team of thugs.

Saturday, January 05, 2008

Zook promises better days ahead...

Or does he?

"I don't think there's any question we'll be a better football team next year," Zook said. "Everyone wants to know: What does that mean?

"I said the second year we'd be a better team than the first and we were, but the record was the same (2-9 in '05, 2-10 in '06). So we will be a better team.
God, it's hard to take anything this moRon says seriously. But let's dissect. He promises the team will be better but he hedges by saying that improvement is not necessarily see in W-L record. You see his 2-10 team in 2006 was "better" than the 2-9 team from 2005. So a 9-4 team in 2008 could conceivably be better than a 9-4 team in 2007.
"Players will be better as juniors and seniors than they were as freshmen and sophomores. That's the way it is as they get experience."

Translation: Zook wouldn't be disappointed by another 9-3 record next season, because it could mean another BCS bowl berth. But it should be a better 9-3.
The thing is that Zook is enamored of his own recruits. You see he had seniors this year, but they weren't his seniors. He thinks that "his" recruits are simply going to yield better results. I'm not so sure. The best player on the Illini this year was Rashard Mendenhall who had committed to Illinois before Ron Turner was fired. And Mendenhall is likely to be playing Sundays next year. There's no doubt that Zook has shown an ability to bring in guys with lots of stars next to their names on the scouting web sites but we'll see how that translates into wins and losses. It's one thing to have diamonds in the rough and quite another to cut those diamonds into precious stones.

For the record I don't think Illinois will repeat a 9 win season next year.

We'll see who is right, me or the Zooker.

Friday, October 05, 2007

The empty cupboard myth shattered

While the pundits heap praise upon Ron Zook for the success the Illini are having (against a very weak schedule thus far), a story is developing far away from Champaign-Urbana. It's the unraveling of the empty cupboard myth that Ron Zook and his supporters created at Florida. But the unraveling is not happening in Gainesville, it's happening in Columbia, South Carolina. Confused yet? Well let me enlighten you.

By now we all know that when Ron Zook was hired to coach the Gators before the 2002 season, that lines were immediately drawn between those that supported the decision and those who shook their collective head and said "huh?". Over time many of us who were on the fence, joined those became more and more vocal about the need to rid ourselves the scourge that was Zook.

At the same time Zook's supporters among the Gator faithful became more and more stubborn in their support, to the point that they unquestioningly bought Zook's explanation that he inherited a Gator team that was devoid of talent. They clung to this myth, even after Zook was finally fired and even attempted to give Zook credit for the Gators BCS championship in the 2006 season.

Now we will see the myth for what it was and what it is: merely a myth.

In order to believe in the proposition that the Gator squad Zook inherited was lacking in talent, you have to believe that Steve Spurrier's recruiting had been going down hill for at least a couple of years. Believers of the myth will say that Spurrier had lost interest in recruiting and in college football. In fact, they'll say he was never really a good recruiter to begin with. They will say that Ron Zook was the secret to Spurrier's success while he was an assistant at Florida. The Florida Gators were headed toward hard times, they will say, whether Spurrier had left or not.

Now let the myth busting begin.

First of all, I am a big believer that the best indicator of future performance is past performance. And by that measure we have no reason to believe (and no evidence to support) the idea that Spurrier had lost his edge, recruiting or otherwise. It's fortunate for the believers of the myth that recruiting records at places like scout.com and rivals.com don't go back far enough to see what Spurrier's recruiting classes looked like in the late 90s and and in 2000.

But let's look at what we do know. Spurrier takes over a hapless Duke team and turns it around, winning an ACC title. He then takes over a mediocre Florida program that is on probation and turns it around, winning several SEC titles and a national title. His last season at Florida (2001), the Gators went 10-2. In his penultimate year (2000) he won an SEC title. So if we are to believe that the 2002 Gators were talentless then we must believe that something happened abruptly which caused Steve Spurrier to completely change his make-up. Show me the evidence, I say.

Spurrier's Cocks were 4-1 and ranked 11th going into tonights game against undefeated and 8th ranked Kentucky. And guess what? Ron Zook didn't recruit a single player on this team. So who did? Spurrier, of course.

South Carolina's recruiting class for 2006 was ranked 33rd in the country by Scout.com. The class included (3) 4-star recruits and (13) 3-star recruits. In contrast, the "master recruiter" Ron Zook had the 28th ranked recruiting class. "Aha!" you say, "it's better than Spurrier." But I quote Lee Corso and say "Not so fast my friend!" Ron Zook's class that year also consisted of (3) 4-star recruits and (13) 3-star recruits. And, in fact, the average rating for Zook's class (2.70) was marginally lower than Spurrier's (2.79). The difference in that ranking lies in the fact that Illinois had 3 more commits than South Carolina. So the idea that Spurrier couldn't recruit without Zook, or somehow lost his recruiting touch takes a serious blow.

Now if you look at the 2007 recruiting classes you'll see that Spurrier managed to bring in the 7th ranked class in the country with (1) 5-star, (13) 4-stars and (13) 3-stars. The average rating was 3.35. Zook on the other hand was much ballyhooed for bringing in the countries 20th ranked class with (2) 5-stars, (5) 4-stars and (8) 3-stars for an average rating of 3.14.

Bang, bang. Another nail in the coffin.

And one thing that I haven't mentioned yet is something that is very important in this whole argument. And that's coaching. You know, what coaches are supposed to do when they aren't recruiting.

Spurrier took a bad team and improved its record in his first year. He improved again in his second year and in his third year he is giving teams in the SEC nightmares. Meanwhile Zook took Florida down a couple of notches and despite his many claims to the contrary, never improved the club. At least not where it counts, in the win column.

The Illini likewise went backward under Zook. Ron Turner won 4 games in his last season at Illinois before he got shitcanned and Zook needed two seasons to win that many. Which brings us to 2007. Yes Illinois is 4-1 Yes they beat Penn State. But to that I say, "so what?" The Big 10 is proving to be terrible again this year. Penn State lost to the team (Michigan) that lost to a 1AA school (Appalachian State).

If the folks at Illinois are happy with the Zooker then I'm happy for them. But please, for the love of God stop peddling the myth that Spurrier didn't or couldn't recruit at the end of his time at Florida. You're embarrassing yourselves.

Wednesday, December 13, 2006

The myth of Ron Zook, master recruiter

Found this great article that summarizes Ron Zook's recruiting history at Florida. I'm posting it in its entirety because I don't know how long the link will be active and I have a feeling that some Illini fans are going to want to read this as next season unfolds.

Was Zook an Ace Recruiter?
By Marty Cohen, GatorBait.net Publisher – Rivals.com

It was generous of Urban Meyer to give some recognition to Ron Zook during the post-BCS announcement press conference last weekend, acknowledging Zook for his recruitment of the upperclassmen on the 2006 SEC champs.

It was nice of Zook to drop his long-held angered stance toward Florida, vote the Gators second in his coaches poll and adopt a warm embrace toward UF's championship run.

And it's a switch to see some Gator fans giving Zook some props for the work he and his staff did in bringing in a bunch of players who eventually led Florida to its first SEC title in six years and a berth in the national championship game.

Now I realize it's the holiday season, and it's the time for good cheer and all that, but this is getting a little thick.

It was definitely gracious of Meyer, who unsolicited, tossed a bone to Zook for leaving behind what amounted to a terrific group of leaders and players who formed the backbone of the '06 squad. Of course, this is the same unbalanced collection of players that Meyer, for two years, has bemoaned the staggering lack of depth, which caused him to play more than a dozen freshmen this fall. And who is responsible for having no depth anywhere on this squad?

It is certainly pleasant to hear Zook saying positive things about Florida, especially since he will likely get some more national pub from media folks around the country who will solicit his feelings, having played Ohio State tough this year and having recruited and coached a number of the Gator players. But it also smacks as a bit self-serving. All of a sudden, the once-supremely bitter Zook is now all lovey-dovey, since it paints himself and his Illinois program in a better light. And don't think for a milli-second that Zook isn't using this in his current recruiting, pointing out to potential Illini prospects that those are "his" recruits playing in the national championship game.

And finally, a segment of Gator fans who rode the Zook train right into the ground, want to fete the man for his recruiting and all the hard work he put in during three sub-standard years at UF. Well the hard work deal is nauseating. Shouldn't everybody out there, from a shoeshine guy to a lowly sportswriter to a head coach making more than a million dollars work hard? Should that really be something that stands out as being praise-worthy?

And in terms of his recruiting prowess, maybe I'm in the minority, but I just don't buy the hype. All coaches get pigeonholed and receive a national perception. Zook's persona is that of the good guy who works hard and is a terrific recruiter. The first part doesn't matter, the second part should be a given and the third part is perhaps more myth than fact.

There is no doubt when you look at Florida's starting lineup, it is littered with Zook recruits – Leak, Baker, Caldwell, Rissler, Miller, Tartt, Trautwein and Medder on offense, Moss, McDonald, Cohen, Harris (not to mention Marcus Thomas), Siler, Everett, Lewis and Joiner on defense, plus Wilbur (I don't count Reggie Nelson, who had to be recruited all over again out of junior college by Meyer's staff).

This is a team top-heavy with contributing seniors, but that's the way it is supposed to be – wasn't Steve Spurrier's first SEC championship team in '91 loaded with fifth-year seniors from Galen Hall's superb 1987 signing class? Of course, that's the way college football works.

But I have maintained all along that Zook's recruiting has been a case of style over substance, a caste-system of five-star upper class guys and a bunch of low-level guys who rarely panned out, with no middle class. It is that middle class which gives a program consistency and reliability, the five-year guys who provide depth as youngsters and become valuable contributors as juniors and seniors.

Frankly, there hasn't been nearly enough of those guys in Zook's recruitment. Again, it's why Florida's depth situation is so dire, why this is a club loaded with seniors, and freshmen (true and redshirt, Meyer's guys), with virtually no junior and sophomore classes. It's why there is no upper-class depth at quarterback, offensive line, linebacker and in the secondary, and why the two-year search still continues for a decent, reliable running back.

Let's take a look at Zook's three recruiting classes, and you decide about his recruiting wizardry. Granted, the first year in 2002 was a hastily-assembled bunch, having less than a month to put a class together when Spurrier abruptly left. In hindsight, it turned out to be a pretty decent group:

Dallas Baker; Nick Brooks; Todd Bunce; Ryan Carter; Taurean Charles; Jemalle Cornelius; Channing Crowder; Brian Crum; Gavin Dickey; Patrick Dosh; Ciatrick Fason; Randy Hand; Steven Harris; Terrence Holmes; Reggie Lewis; Jermaine McCollum; Tremaine McCollum; Ray McDonald; MacKenzie Pierre; Kenneth Tookes; Jimtavis Walker; DeShawn Wynn.

There were only six washouts who never did anything at UF and most were prime contributors, with a few stars (Baker, who was technically a Spurrier recruit, Crowder, Fason and McDonald) and a lot of solid contributors (Cornelius, Crum, Dickey, Hand, Harris, Holmes, Lewis, T. McCollum and Wynn).

The 2003 class was supposed to Zook's shining achievement as a recruiter, a Top 2 or 3 class that he hung his hat on forever. There is no doubt this class has some stars, but there were simply too many guys who contributed little to nothing, including the ill-fated junior college venture, essentially wasting a half-dozen scholarships (save one year from offensive tackle Tavares Washington). Here it is:

Andre Caldwell; Joe Cohen; Johnny Dingle; Earl Everett; Billy Griffin; Anthony Guerrero; Michael Hill; Reynaldo Hill; Eric Holcombe; Chad Jackson; David Kenner; Chris Leak; Howard Lingard; Clint McMillan; Carlton Medder; Justin Midgett; Tranell Morant; Jarvis Moss; Julian Riley; Steve Rissler; Jermaine Thomas; Marcus Thomas; Skyler Thornton; Tavares Washington; Dee Webb; Eric Wilbur.

Again, this was the quintessential no middle-class group, with a lot of star power (Caldwell, Cohen, Everett, Jackson, Leak, Moss, M. Thomas, Webb and Wilbur), way too many washouts (Dingle, Griffin, Guerrero, M. Hill, Holcombe, Kenner, Lingard, Midgett, Morant, Riley, J. Thomas and Thornton) and only a handful of middle-ground guys (R. Hill, McMillan, Medder, Rissler and I guess, Washington). If you're truly going to judge a recruiting class three or four years down the road, then personally, this one gets downgraded from its lofty perch – half the class did absolutely nothing at UF.

Just completing year number three, Zook's final UF recruiting class in 2004 hasn't packed much of a punch. This is where the depth is supposed to come from, a large number of players either starting or pushing for starting jobs. While it's too early to cast aside some players who are still at UF, there have been few potential stars produced and again, way too many players no longer with the program. Here's a look:

Michael Brown; Tate Casey; Branden Daniel; Javier Estopinan; Dawayne Grace; Dane Guthrie; Derrick Harvey; Cornelius Ingram; Kyle Jackson; Tony Joiner; Mike Mangold; Markus Manson; Mike McIntosh; Derrick McPhearson; Drew Miller; Jeremy Mincey; McIntosh Nicolas; Eric Rutledge; Brandon Siler; Jim Tartt; Markell Thompson; Phil Trautwein; Jason Watkins.

Nearly half this class was gone by year three and it was not all a result of a coaching change – Brown, Daniel, Grace, Guthrie, Mangold, McIntosh, McPhearson, Nicholas and of course, Mincey and Thompson who were junior college signees. That's way too much attrition. There are some definite stars – Siler and Miller – some main contributors who've earned starting spots – Casey, Joiner, Tartt and Trautwein – some guys with big upsides – Harvey, Ingram – and five others who've played a role the last two years (Estopinan, Jackson, Manson, Rutledge and Watkins).

There it is, you guys decide about Zook's recruiting. Personally, I wouldn't say it was all that great. It was solid, and did produce a number of stars in one class. But once again, there is a reason why Meyer has been decrying the lack of depth at just about every position, why there is no consistent big-time veteran running back on campus and why so many freshmen (probably a dozen by the time the medical redshirts are used) had to play this year.

Heck, I've taken my shots at Zook over the years and for very personal reasons that I won't get into – no matter how hard some of you may ask – harbor no good tidings for the guy. But since everything is upbeat concerning Florida football, far be it from me to douse the moment. Just figured I'd toss some items out there to chew on while we're handing out the holiday hosannas.

Tuesday, December 05, 2006

The Myth of Ron Zook

Zookism is a cult. In order to belong to the cult you have to drink the Kool-Aid. Like any cult, there is a mythology surrounding it. In Zookism's case a big part of the mythology surrounds the proverbial cupboard.

You see there once was a house in Gainesville and when Ron Zook moved in the cupboard was bare. Ron worked hard, very hard in fact he hardly got any sleep, to buy the groceries (and by buying we may be using a metaphor and we may not be depending on who you believe). And Ron loaded that cupboard up only to be thanklessly evicted.

So it's no surprise that Ron Zook rated the Gators number 2 in his coaches poll ballot. You see Urban Meyer is winning with his groceries players. This only helps build up the Zookist mythology.

But like all cults, the mythology is far from the reality. When Steve Spurrier lived in the same house as Zook he took the groceries that were there and immediately whipped up some fantastic meals. When he would shop for groceries he's often bring back the ingredients that didn't have fancy packaging or that were loaded with empty calories, he brought back real stuff that was often overlooked by other grocery shoppers and worked wonders with it. He was a true chef coach.

Zook on the other hand was like a child. If he saw a commercial for a breakfast cereal on TV he immediately wanted it, especially if there was a toy trinket inside. The fact is that the cupboard wasn't bare when Ron Zook moved into that house in Gainesville, it was loaded with good stuff that Zook wasn't interested in.

For those of you former Zookists there is hope. Keep reading this blog and go to places like Zook Free Zone. You'll be deprogrammed in no time.